Go to main contentsGo to main menu
Friday, July 3, 2026 at 6:36 PM

Physical Therapy or Joint Replacement? Insights from Dr. Stephen Reed, HCA Florida Lake Monroe Hospital

Physical Therapy or Joint Replacement? Insights from Dr. Stephen Reed, HCA  Florida Lake Monroe Hospital

Special to the Herald

 

In my practice, I’m seeing more of our population than ever before – the young and old, active and sedentary – experiencing chronic and persistent joint pain.

The reasons are well documented. First, we’re living longer and, as we age, we naturally increase the likelihood of experiencing joint problems. When we are more engaged in physical activity, the result can be long-term wear and tear of bones, joints and tissue. Meanwhile, rates of chronic obesity, which places excessive weight on bones and joints, continue to skyrocket.

Even more troubling is the increasing number of younger individuals experiencing significant joint pain, typically due to constant motion and strain on the body caused by participation in year-round baseball, gymnastics and other sports. 

Regardless of the patient’s circumstance, the issue of alleviating bone and joint pain starts with the same question: is physical therapy or joint replacement the best approach?  

To determine the best course of action, a comprehensive assessment is essential. This starts with understanding what I like to call the individual’s “pain and function meters,” the essential indicators that help determine the severity of their condition and the impact it has on their daily life. 

One’s subjective pain meter gives us a window into the intensity and frequency of pain, while the patient’s function meter assesses how much the pain limits their ability to perform everyday activities. By understanding these metrics, we can better tailor a treatment approach to each individual.

Non-operative measures, such as physical therapy services are always considered first. Physical therapy is a cornerstone of non-surgical treatments, strengthening the muscles around the joint, improving flexibility, and reducing pain. For many patients, especially those who are active and wish to stay engaged in their favorite activities without surgery, physical therapy can be incredibly effective. 

However, there are instances where physical therapy and other non-operative measures may not be sufficient. When patients have exhausted these options and still experience debilitating pain or limited function, joint replacement may be the best course of action. This is particularly true for those whose quality of life is severely impacted, making everyday tasks challenging.

Fortunately, advancements in imaging and diagnostic techniques, as well as the advent of robotic-assisted surgeries, which are offered at HCA Florida Lake Monroe Hospital, have revolutionized joint replacement. These technological advancements allow for unparalleled precision, leading to quicker recoveries thanks to the minimally invasive nature of these procedures. Additionally, the longevity of implants has improved, making joint replacement a more viable long-term solution for many patients.

To be clear, the decision between physical therapy and joint replacement is not a one-size-fits-all approach. It requires a thorough evaluation of each patient's pain and function levels, as well as consideration of their overall health and lifestyle. 

By understanding the trends and advancements in joint treatment, we can make informed decisions that best suit the needs of each individual. Whether through physical therapy or joint replacement, the ultimate goal is to help patients live a pain-free and active lifestyle, ensuring they can enjoy daily activities and improve their overall quality of life.

 


Share
Rate

Join Our Mailing List